We have detected that you are using an adblocking plugin in your browser.

The revenue we earn by the advertisements is used to manage this website. Please whitelist our website in your adblocking plugin.

SCRUTINY | Melody Is King In 2016 Westben Arts Festival Opener The Pencil Salesman

By Joseph So on June 27, 2016

The Pencil Salesman, albeit a bit of a work in progress, is a welcome addition to the Canadian canon of contemporary music drama.

The Pencil Salesman (Photo courtesy Westben Arts Festival)
The Pencil Salesman (Photo courtesy Westben Arts Festival)

World Premiere Saturday, June 25, at The Barn, Westben Arts Festival. Additional performances June 26, July 1, 2, and 3.

CAMPBELLFORD, ON — With the world premiere of The Pencil Salesman yesterday afternoon, the 17th chapter of the Westben Arts Festival’s opening has been written — pun intended. This one was extra-special because of the unveiling of a brand new opera by pianist-composer Brian Finley, who together with his wife soprano Donna Bennett are the driving forces behind the Westben Arts Festival, a musical haven in the Trent Hills, a scenic area located along the Trent Severn Waterway in Northumberland County, a leisurely two-hour drive east of Toronto. I’ve heard about the Festival for years but never had the pleasure of seeing a performance there. I am glad I finally remedied that yesterday. The show took place in the rustic venue known as The Barn. I don’t know the seating capacity, but my guess is it’s under 200. It’s not air conditioned and on a warm day like yesterday, it was slightly uncomfortable. I was fortunate enough to be near one of the many free-standing — and surprisingly silent but powerful — fans in the auditorium. It was quite a long opera, slightly over 2 ½ hours with a short intermission. A full house, the famously loyal and supportive Westben audience made up mostly of local folks, gave it an enthusiastic reception.

I recently interviewed Brian Finley, the artistic director of Westben and the composer-librettist of The Pencil Salesman.  In our chat, he spoke extensively about the genesis of this work, commissioned by his friend, Dr Agnes Herzberg, Professor Emeritus of Statistics at Queen’s University. The heart of this multi-layered story has to do with human connectedness in the modern age. It underscores how technology, meant to enhance human communication, ironically hinders it, especially on the more profound, interpersonal, face-to-face level. The story is told through the eyes of its protagonist, the family patriarch, Boris Ball (baritone John Fanning), the inventor of the “Personal Touch” typewriter. As the world moves on from his invention to other devices such as the computer and the mobile phone, Boris Ball, instead of accepting the future, continues to cling to the past, to the memory of his dead wife Rose (soprano Donna Bennett), shutting himself off from the younger generation — son Edward (tenor Keith Klassen) and his wife Daisy (soprano Virginia Hatfield) and their daughter Violet. It’s up to a chance encounter with the pivotal Pencil Salesman (bass-baritone Alex Dobson), the catalyst in Boris’s eventual reconnection with his estranged family, that he finally chooses to embrace the future.

The Pencil Salesman (Photo courtesy Westben Arts Festival)
The Pencil Salesman (Photo courtesy Westben Arts Festival)

Musically it’s a conservative work, with a formal structure that recalls classical compositions of the past, but with just enough harmonic modulations and dissonances here and there so it won’t be mistaken for a piece from the past. There are clearly defined arias — in fact; spoken dialogue invariably leads to song. There’s an amusing choral number of the Personal Touch TM Factory, a moment that allows the chorus to shine.  There’s even a cleverly constructed “Happy Birthday Fugue.” Finley reserves his most inspired melody for the final duet between Boris and his dead wife, Rose. The opera ends with Boris finally letting go of the past, and the memory of his dead wife, to embrace the future. I find the ending surprisingly powerful and moving.

Much of the credit goes to the strong ensemble cast, led by veteran baritone John Fanning. In good voice, his Boris has the proper dramatic gravitas without being overly crusty and unsympathetic. Soprano Donna Bennett is a perfect foil as his wife Rose, and she sang with clear, well focused, lovely tone. Equally fine was the gleaming soprano of Virginia Hatfield as Daisy, a role with a considerable dramatic/emotional range. Keith Klassen brought his bright tenor and typically engaging personality to the role of the son Edward. Supporting characters were all ably taken, particularly Flo (Gabrielle Prata), Aaron (Robert Longo) and the young Violet of Olivia Rapos. And of course one mustn’t forget the title role of the Pencil Salesman, mellifluously sung and deftly acted by Alexander Dobson, who also doubled as Frank.  Finley tailored the vocal writing for each character to the individual singer, a luxury that’s only possible in original creations. The twenty-member chamber orchestra played well under the knowing baton of Daniel Warren. Composer Brian Finley contributed on the keyboard, playing beautifully, particularly the Mozart sonata-like main theme that recurs periodically throughout the opera.

Final impressions?  The Pencil Salesman is quite an enjoyable show, albeit a bit of a work in progress. It combines classical music sensibilities with inspired melodies in the best Bernstein and Musical tradition. To say this piece sounds like a musical is not a put-down but a compliment. The goal, after all, is to tell a story and to touch an audience. Too often with contemporary classical music from Schoenberg Berg and Webern to Stockhausen Cage and Carter, the urge to break new musical ground means the audience leaving the theatre unmoved, or worse, befuddled. Not the case with The Pencil Salesman, a very human story expressed in accessible and tonal music. If I were to quibble, I fine that there’s so much detail in the plot — a rather ambitious total of 7 vignettes — that it makes the first act a bit unwieldy. In Act Two, there are some noticeable gaps in the story-telling. Michael Mori has done a good job with his directing, but I think some judicious cuts, especially with the material that’s not essential to the main story, would tighten it considerably. Finley has injected quite a bit of humour into the proceedings but for some reason, much of it seemed lost to the opening audience. That being said, all in all, it was a good effort. With a bit of fine-tuning, it certainly will be a welcome addition to the Canadian canon of contemporary music drama.

#LUDWIGVAN

Want more updates on Toronto-centric classical music news and review before anyone else finds out? Get our exclusive newsletter here and follow us on Facebook for all the latest.

Joseph So

Share this article
lv_toronto_banner_high_590x300
comments powered by Disqus

FREE ARTS NEWS STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX, EVERY MONDAY BY 6 AM

company logo

Part of

Terms of Service & Privacy Policy
© 2024 | Executive Producer Moses Znaimer