DESKTOP
TABLET (max. 1024px)
MOBILE (max. 640px)
Return to Top
Ludwig Van
Toronto Montreal

RECORD KEEPING | The Unpredictable Rufus Wainwright

By Paul E. Robinson on June 18, 2016

Rufus Wainwright | Prima Donna
Rufus Wainwright: Prima Donna. Janis Kelly and Kathryn Guthrie, sopranos. Antonio Figueroa, tenor. Richard Morrison, baritone. BBC Symphony/Jayce Ogren. DG 479 5340. Total Time: 128.00 (2 CDs).

It is difficult to say in a few words who Rufus Wainwright is or what he does.  Let me start by saying simply that he is Canadian-born and multi-talented. After that it gets complicated and in some circles, controversial. Since Musical Toronto is a classical music website, I will concentrate on his work in this area, but also note that he is very active and very successful as a pop singer and that he will soon be appearing in Toronto at the Luminato Festival (June 23-24), channelling Judy Garland (stay tuned for MT’s review on that next week).

About ten years ago, Wainwright was commissioned by the Metropolitan Opera to write an opera. Soon afterwards, the commission fell apart and was cancelled when Wainwright insisted that the opera be sung in French. Eventually, Prima Donna was produced for the Manchester International Festival and given its world premiere July 10, 2009. Later, it was done at Luminato in Toronto and Brooklyn. The reviews were mixed, to say the least. Going in, some critics were sceptical that a pop artist could write a ‘real’ opera and coming out; some concluded that their apprehensions had been justified.

Not having seen any of the performances referred to here, I can’t weigh in on the merits of the criticism; I can only give my impressions of the work as heard on this new DG recording.

Let me begin with a brief account of the origin of the work and a summary of the plot. Wainwright says that he was inspired to write the opera after seeing Lord Harewood, at one time the head of the Edinburgh Festival, interview Maria Callas on DVD. Apparently, Wainwright had always idolised Callas as an opera singer, and this interview underscored the pain a great artist may endure in nearing the end of her career.

The opera Prima Donna is not about Maria Callas but rather about any singer of advanced age and declining powers who must say farewell to the operatic stage. There are only four characters in this full-length opera: the prima donna, Régine Saint Laurent; her maid Marie; her butler Philippe and a journalist named André Letourneur. The story follows Régine, who last appeared on stage six years ago in the lead role of Aliénor d’Aquitaine (Eleanor of Aquitaine), as she prepares to return to the stage in that same opera. She is seriously apprehensive. A journalist comes to interview her, a young man who knows this opera by heart, and she falls in love with him. Then it turns out that he is not in love with her – although he admires her greatly — but is engaged to be married to another woman. Régine’s confidence is destroyed once again, and she refuses to go forward with her planned return to the stage. As she watches the fireworks go off outside her Paris window — it is Bastille Day — she realises that her career is over, and perhaps her love life too, and sings her final words in the opera: “The fireworks are over. It didn’t last long.”

While the Prima Donna story can’t help but elicit memories of Richard Strauss’ operas Capriccio and Der Rosenkavalier, the musical style of this piece is more like a mix of Puccini and Chabrier. But, you might say, “Didn’t these composers close the book on this style, for the most part, at the top of their game?” To which I would reply: “Who dictated that a composer in 2009 had to write in a contemporary style? Are there rules about this?” Personally, I have no problem with composers who wish to be eclectic. To my mind, the only relevant question should be: “Have they done it successfully?” In the case of Prima Donna, I would answer “Yes!” Wainwright has created real characters and explored their emotions with genuine insight. I found the entire opera compelling and deeply moving.

Some critics have questioned whether, in fact, Wainwright was capable of writing a work for large orchestra, and on this scale. In the notes for this CD, Wainwright answers his doubters: “I, Rufus Wainwright, absolutely fully and totally orchestrated this entire opera myself.”

If this is indeed true, he has done an amazing job — judging by this recording; that said, on a recording, the solo voices have no problem cutting through the heavy orchestration, whereas in a live performance, this might prove difficult. Wainwright seems to have a particular affection for high woodwinds (Chabrier?) and tuba, but that is OK. The sound of his orchestration is distinctive and mostly very effective. One wonders, however, if he might have varied the orchestration with greater use of solo instruments and small groups from time to time.

Wainwright’s writing for Régine is excellent and Janis Kelly gives a terrific performance. On the other hand, coloratura soprano Kathryn Guthrie is too often made to sing in her highest register (to the point of screeching). Then again, perhaps that is the point. Tenor Antonio Figueroa likewise is given more than his share of high notes to navigate. He does well, but Wainwright could have shown him a little more mercy. Baritone Richard Morrison is excellent as the long-time butler who has devoted his life to Régine, and who takes her final withdrawal from the stage as a personal insult.

Rufus Wainwright | Take All My Loves: 9 Shakespeare Sonnets
Rufus Wainwright | Take All My Loves: 9 Shakespeare Sonnets

In the Shakespeare CD, Take All My Loves: 9 Shakespeare Sonnets, Wainwright has coupled readings of nine of the sonnets with his setting of those same poems for voice and orchestra. Many of the actors reading the sonnets are very experienced thespians, and Austrian soprano Anna Prohaska who sings most of the songs is a joy to hear. One of the songs, a setting of Sonnet 20 “A Woman’s Face”, is exceptionally beautiful and should have a life of its own in the repertoire.

Rufus Wainwright | Rufus Does Judy at Carnegie Hall
Rufus Does Judy at Carnegie Hall. Geffen Records 1751672 (2 CDs).

In 1961, American singer, actress, and vaudevillian Judy Garland (1922-1969) gave a now-legendary concert in Carnegie Hall. In 2006, Rufus Wainwright decided that he would recreate that concert with the original songs, the original band arrangements, with himself in the role of Judy Garland. Again, the reviews were mixed. NY Times critic Stephen Holden wrote that ‘Mr. Wainwright sounds nothing like Judy Garland, his voice is an astringent drone with a quavering edge, uncertain intonation and slightly garbled diction, and isn’t half as good an instrument as Garland’s.” For all that, Holden concluded that Wainwright had pulled it off: “Mr. Wainwright’s courage to stand as a surrogate for every Garland fan who ever gazed into a mirror and fantasised about stepping into her ruby slippers spoke for itself. Simply for doing it, he was a hero.” Perhaps Luminato audiences will agree when Rufus Wainwright channels Judy Garland in Toronto next week.

Multi-talented? No doubt about it. In over his head? Sometimes. Nonetheless, one of the most creative and unpredictable composer-performers in our midst today.

#LUDWIGVAN

Want more updates on Toronto-centric classical music news and review before anyone else finds out? Get our exclusive newsletter here and follow us on Twitter for all the latest.

Share this article
lv_toronto_banner_high_590x300
comments powered by Disqus

Ludwig Van Toronto

LEBRECHT LISTENS | Johannes Moser And Maximilian Hornung Make Fair Arguments For Cello Concertos

By Norman Lebrecht on November 16, 2018

This week, Norman Lebrecht highlights two new Cello concerto albums by Johannes Moser and Hornung Maximilian.
Read the full story Comments
Share this article
lv_toronto_banner_high_590x300

SCRUTINY | We Came For Boléro But Stayed For City Noir

By Stephan Bonfield on November 22, 2018

While Ravel's Bolero was eaten up by a cavernous Roy Thomson Hall, it was the TSO's performance of John Adams' retro-styled City Noir that won us over.
Read the full story Comments
Share this article

THE LUDWIG VAN GUIDE | To Not Writing A Symphony

By Michael Vincent on November 21, 2018

There are many ways to not write a symphony, but in our experience, it's best to acknowledge that no one actually knows how to write a symphony.
Read the full story Comments
Share this article
lv_toronto_banner_low_590x300
lv_toronto_ssb_atf_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_high_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_mid_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_low_300x300
lv_toronto_tsb_high_300x700
lv_toronto_tsb_low_300x700
lv_toronto_ssb_atf_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_high_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_mid_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_low_300x300
lv_toronto_tsb_high_300x700
lv_toronto_tsb_low_300x700

We have detected that you are using an adblocking plugin in your browser.

The revenue we earn by the advertisements is used to manage this website. Please whitelist our website in your adblocking plugin.