DESKTOP
TABLET (max. 1024px)
MOBILE (max. 640px)
Return to Top
Ludwig Van
Toronto Montreal

LEBRECHT LISTENS | Is This The Holy Grail Of Mahler 3 Recordings?

By Ludwig Van on May 5, 2017

Iván Fischer (Photo courtesy Budapest Festival Orchestra)
Iván Fischer (Photo courtesy Budapest Festival Orchestra)

Mahler: Third Symphony (Channel Classics)

★★/★★★★ (out of five)

There is no wholly recommendable performance on record of Mahler’s third symphony. The earliest, by F. Charles Adler in 1952, is faultlessly idiomatic, as is Jascha Horenstein’s 1970 LSO account, but both are marred by inferior orchestral playing and poor sound.

Claudio Abbado’s 2007 DVD from Lucerne is as good as it gets, though even a lifelong Mahlerian like Abbado struggles with the lop-sidedness of this amalgam of nostalgic pastoralism and saloon-bar philosophy. No-one can satisfactorily explain what Friedrich Nietzsche is getting at in the fourth movement contralto solo. It’s just odd.

If you listen just to the second disc in this package, you may soon be convinced that this is the long-awaited holy grail of a perfect Mahler Third. You can almost smell the mown grass in the second movement and see the frolicking lambs in the third. The Nietzsche admonition is gently delivered by Gerhild Romberger and the two choruses, child, and adult, are just fine. The twenty-minute adagio finale is languor itself. And the Budapest Festival Orchestra are, as ever, full of character and guile.

The problem is the first disc, containing the opening movement, which seems here to last forever. The timing, 33 minutes, is identical to Horenstein, Barbirolli and sprightly Simon Rattle, but Ivan Fischer makes it feel much longer. His world-weariness contrasts with the rage and aggression conjured by other conductors. I can guess what Fischer is trying to convey — Mahler’s helplessness against the loss of rural idylls — but it doesn’t ring true to me. This is a performance of two halves, each deserving a different set of stars.

Mahler: Third Symphony (Channel Classics) is available at Amazon.ca.

For more weekly reviews by Norman Lebrecht, see HERE.

Visit Slipped Disc HERE.

#LUDWIGVAN

Norman Lebrecht

Norman Lebrecht is one of the most widely-read commentators on music, culture and cultural politics. He is a regular presenter on BBC Radio 3 and a contributor to the Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg, Standpoint, Sinfini and other publications. His blog, Slipped Disc, is among the most widely read cultural sites online, breaking exclusive stories and campaigning against human abuse and acts of injustice in the cultural industries.

Share this article
lv_toronto_banner_high_590x300
comments powered by Disqus

Ludwig Van Toronto

CMIM 2018 | Day Two: Aria Competition First Round (Sessions 1 & 2) Inches Closer To Semi-Finals

By Joseph So on May 31, 2018

Ludwig van Toronto continues our coverage from the 2018 Concours musical international de Montréal, which yesterday saw 16 singers battle it out in the Aria Division.
Read the full story Comments
Share this article
lv_toronto_banner_high_590x300

SCRUTINY | COC Ensemble Ends Season With A Few Goodbyes Of Their Own

By Joseph So on May 26, 2018

Sopranos Danika Lorèn and Samantha Pickett, mezzo Megan Quick, and baritone Bruno Roy bid farewell to COC Ensemble Studio before leaving the nest in the final concert of the season.
Read the full story Comments
Share this article

SCRUTINY | Two TSO Concerts For The Price Of One, Plus A Bonus Jon Kimura Parker

By Arthur Kaptainis on June 14, 2018

Rather than ponder the imponderable and seek to understand why Gershwin’s Concerto in F and Brahms’s First Symphony are not compatible, let's accept the Toronto Symphony Orchestra outing as two concerts separated by an intermission.
Read the full story Comments
Share this article
lv_toronto_banner_low_590x300
lv_toronto_ssb_atf_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_high_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_mid_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_low_300x300
lv_toronto_tsb_high_300x700
lv_toronto_tsb_low_300x700
lv_toronto_ssb_atf_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_high_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_mid_300x300
lv_toronto_ssb_low_300x300
lv_toronto_tsb_high_300x700
lv_toronto_tsb_low_300x700

We have detected that you are using an adblocking plugin in your browser.

The revenue we earn by the advertisements is used to manage this website. Please whitelist our website in your adblocking plugin.